Why Punishment Doesn’t Work for Kids with ADHD, and What to Try Instead

This weekend wasn’t my finest parenting moment.

It was busy. The kids were tired, emotions were high, and by Sunday afternoon, I lost my patience. It wasn’t pretty, and if you're parenting a child or teen with ADHD, I imagine you’ve had a moment like this too.

But beating ourselves up doesn’t help. What does help is stepping back and remembering what actually supports an ADHD brain and (spoiler alert!) it’s not punishment.

Instead, the most effective ADHD parenting strategies focus on teaching skills, building connection, and supporting emotional regulation. Even small shifts can have a big impact.

Why Traditional Punishment Fails for Kids and Teens with ADHD

If your child didn’t do their homework, ignored the curfew you gave them, or was rude this weekend, it’s natural to think about a consequence: “No phone for 48 hours,” or “You’re grounded.” This approach has been the default for generations. But for kids with ADHD, here’s why punishment usually doesn’t work:

1. Time Blindness Means Delayed Consequences Don’t Stick

Children and teens with ADHD often struggle with time awareness. They live in the "now" and find it difficult to link past actions with future consequences. A punishment handed out hours (or days) later often feels random and confusing to them.

2. Punishment Triggers Shame, Not Learning

Harsh consequences can activate the fight-or-flight response in kids with ADHD. When shame or defensiveness kicks in, their brains can’t access the reflection or problem-solving skills they need to actually change behaviour.

3. Punishment Damages Trust

If your child feels constantly criticised or misunderstood, your relationship will suffer. ADHD brains already face a lot of negative feedback — which can lead to low self-esteem and resistance, not cooperation.

4. It Doesn’t Teach Executive Function Skills

ADHD-related behaviours (like forgetting things, being late, interrupting, or acting impulsively) stem from lagging executive function skills, not disrespect. Punishment doesn’t teach time management, emotional control, or planning — but your support can.

ADHD Parenting Strategy: Focus on Teaching, Not Punishing

Instead of focusing on what your child did wrong, shift your attention to what skill they’re struggling with, and how you can help them build it.

Here’s an example:

❌ Instead of: “You forgot your homework again? No phone for two days.”

✅ Try: “It looks like you’re struggling to get things done on time. What could help you remember next time?”

This opens the door to collaboration and skill-building, rather than shame. You might brainstorm solutions together, like:

• Setting an alarm or calendar reminder

• Creating a visual after-school routine

• Getting a gentle text from you at the right time

• Using a “before bed” checklist

These are practical ADHD parenting strategies that support executive functioning, and they actually teach your child how to do better next time.

You Don’t Have to Be a Perfect Parent to Raise a Resilient ADHD Teen

Let’s be honest: we all lose it sometimes. Parenting a child with ADHD is full-on, and it's easy to fall back on what we were taught.

But when we focus on repair, reflection, and relationship, we move in the right direction. You don’t have to get it right every time — but aiming to guide your child rather than punish them will strengthen your connection and build their capacity to thrive.

ADHD Resource of the Week

📚 Book Recommendation: The Whole-Brain Child by Dr. Dan Siegel and Tina Payne Bryson

If you’re navigating ADHD parenting and wondering how to actually support brain development and emotional growth this book is a must-read. It explains how the brain develops and why strategies like emotional coaching, connection, and problem-solving are more effective than traditional discipline.

There’s a teen-focused version too, but I always recommend starting here.

Want More ADHD Parenting Tools?

• ✉️ Join our newsletter for weekly ADHD parenting strategies

• 📲 Follow @drpippamoran on Instagram for tips and videos

You're not alone — and every small change you make matters. You’re helping grow their brain (and your own) with each step forward.